Heroes, Conscripts & Deserters

BRAVERY

In 1862 the Confederate Congress passed an act to authorize the award of medals and badges of distinction to soldiers as a “reward for courage and good conduct on the field of battle.”  The Confederacy did not have the manufacturing capability to make badges, so on October 3, 1863, the Confederate Adjutant and Inspector General’s Office changed the award from a badge to having the soldier’s name read at the head of his regiment at the first dress parade after its receipt and having his name published in at least one newspaper in his home state.

2,053 men were posted to the roll of honor during the war, and of that number, 373 were awarded to Mississippians – the highest number issued to a single state of the Confederacy.

The big difference between the Confederate Roll of Honor and the Union Medal of Honor was that the enlisted men in the southern army got to choose the men placed on the roll.  According to the regulations issued by the Adjutant and Inspector General’s Office, “The noncommissioned officers and privates are authorized, at the first dress-parade after each victory the company shall have assisted to achieve, to distinguish, by a majority of their votes, one private or noncommissioned officer most conspicuous for gallantry and good conduct in the battle.  Should more than one soldier be hereafter selected by a company, as equal in merit, the name to announced on the roll will be determined by lot.  Commissioned officers, distinguished for gallantry on the field, are not to be selected by the vote of the company, battalion or regiment to which they belong, but a statement of their special good conduct should be made by their immediate commander, and forwarded, through the regular channel, to this office.” – The Official Confederate Roll of Honor.

Participation in the roll of honor was voluntary, and many Mississippi units did not choose men for the roll.  They felt that with so many men displaying bravery in battle, it was wrong to single out one person for a special honor.

Mississippians distinguished themselves on battlefields throughout the south and in every theater of the conflict.  To give just one example, at the battle of Murfreesboro, Tennessee, December 30, 1862 – January 1, 1863, so many Mississippians died trying to take a strong Federal position in a small skirt of woods that afterwards the area was known as the “Mississippian’s Half-Acre or Hell’s Half-Acre

Private John W. Simmons of the 27th Mississippi Infantry was involved in the fight at the Mississippian’s Half Acre, and after the war he wrote, “I believe I saw as much war as any man in it, never being absent, but I never in all the war saw as many dead men of one single command in so small a place, as I did there on the plains of Murfreesboro.  Attala County ought to erect a monument on the spot to mark the place where her gallant sons fell.The Attala Ledger, May 17, 1897.

The Mississippians who fought so gallantly for their state were well motivated; they were defending their homes and their very way of life from a ruthless invader.  Sergeant Major John T. Kern of the 45th Mississippi Infantry wrote of this in his diary saying, “We have passed through some of the prettiest country on this move that I have ever seen, it is hard to give up so much of our Dixie to the vandal hordes of Lincoln.  God will surely aid us in driving them back to their bleak north and give us our goodly land in his own good time when he finds we have suffered enough and are worthy.” – Diary of John T. Kern, May 22, 1864.  Original diary is at the Old Court House Museum, Vicksburg, MS.

Colonel Winchester B. Shelby of the 39th Mississippi spoke of the motivation his men had to fight when he wrote his report on the siege of Port Hudson, Louisiana:  “I trust I may be pardoned for saying a few words with reference to my own regiment.  The conduct of officers & men alike meets with my unqualified approbation.  They evinced that spirit which ever activates men fighting for the Holiest of Causes Freedom & their homes…” – Report of Colonel Winchester B. Shelby, Tulane University Library, New Orleans, LA.

Very often, the officers of Mississippi troops had to inspire their men with a display of personal bravery, very often at great risk to themselves.  One example of this is found in the Official Records:  “I cannot speak too highly of the conduct of the troops under my command.  Lieutenant Colonel Reed, temporarily commanding the Fifth Mississippi Cavalry, was pre-eminently daring, and fell mortally wounded while standing on the rifle pits and encouraging his men to the charge, and Lieutenant Burton was killed at his side.” – Report of General James R. Chalmers on the capture of Fort Pillow, Tennessee.  Official Records, Series 1, Volume 32, Part 1, Page 622.

Sometimes the loss of a relative or friend would bring out an almost suicidal bravery in a soldier.  Major Robert Stiles of the Richmond Howitzers witnessed this in Judson Smith of the 21st Mississippi Infantry after his brother William was killed at the battle of Savage Station, Virginia on June 29, 1862.  Stiles wrote that Judson was “altogether deranged” by the death of his brother, and when the 21st Mississippi attacked Malvern Hill on July 1, “…when the regiment, on its first charge, stopped ascending that fearful slope of death and turned back, Jud. Smith did not stop.  He went right on, never returned and was never seen or heard of again.”  To make the story even more tragic, when their father heard of the loss of his only two sons, …he left home, joined Price’s army as a private soldier, and at Iuka did just as his eldest son had done at Malvern Hill, which was the last ever seen or heard of him, and the family became extinct..” – Four Years Under Marse Robert, pages 116-117.

Not all Mississippians were brave soldiers who gallantly fought the enemy for four years; there were also cowards and deserters to be found in ranks as well.  Many of the problems with cowardice and desertion stemmed from the use of conscription by the Confederate army that forced many men to serve against their will.

CONSCRIPTION

By the spring of 1862 the Confederacy found itself facing a manpower shortage with not enough men volunteering to join the army.  To remedy this situation, on April 16, 1862, the Confederate Congress passed the first conscription law in American History, drafting for three years all white males between 18 and 35 who were not legally exempt.  As the war continued and southern losses grew, the conscription age was raised to 45 in September 1862 and by February 1864, the limits were 17 and 50.

Exempted from the draft were certain occupations critical to the war effort and to the home front, such as railroad workers, telegraph operators, and druggists.  The most controversial exemption allowed the owner or overseer of a plantation with twenty or more slaves to be free from the draft.  Known as the Twenty-Negro Law, this exemption proved to be very unpopular.  Another widely disliked exemption was the substitution system, where a man could pay another man not liable to the draft to serve in his stead.  These last two exemptions were hated by the common people of the Confederacy who called it “A rich man’s war and a poor man’s fight.”  As the manpower shortage worsened as the war went on, both of these measures were abolished.

Reaction to the Confederate draft was very negative, particularly in regions that were poor and had few slaves.  In the end about ½ of those drafted reported for duty, producing about 120,000 soldiers throughout the Confederacy, about 20% of all Rebel soldiers.

DESERTION

Desertion was a problem that plagued the Confederate army from the very earliest days of its existence, and the problem only got worse as the war went on and the conflict began to turn against the south.

Part of the desertion problem stemmed from the fact that southern soldiers were very individualistic and had a hard time accepting the discipline that army life required.  Private Joseph Pendleton of the 38th Mississippi Infantry summed up this attitude in a letter to his sister when he wrote, “I am getting tired of being bound when I cannot go when I please I always wanted to be free.”  – Pendleton Letters, Confederate Research Center, Hillsboro, TX.

Many southerners felt that the army treated them like slaves, something they were very sensitive about.  Many volunteers in the army believed they were no better than slaves when a provision of the conscription act in 1862 extended the terms of volunteers already in the service to an additional three years.  In 1864 their enlistments were extended to the duration of the war, and only a crippling wound, chronic disease, or death could release a soldier from the army.

Although the draft brought many men into the Confederate army, the quality of these men was often very poor, and many sought to desert at the first opportunity.  One Mississippi regiment that had extensive problems with deserters was the 38th Mississippi Infantry.  Organized in the spring of 1862, the regiment contained a number of men who were conscripts or who had joined the unit to avoid the stigma of being labeled a conscript.

The unreliability of these conscripts in the 38th Mississippi was realized during the Corinth campaign, as many of these men slipped away from the regiment and went home.  Colonel Preston Brent, commander of the 38th later wrote his wife that the morning of the battle he left camp with 314 men but arrived on the field with only 150.  He explained to her the reason for the loss:  “This was owing a great deal to the fatiguing march that we had to make the morning of the battle, and a great deal to the cowardice of some of the men, that never had any fight in them or ever will.  I have heard from most of them and they were on their way home, no doubt they will tell great tale of what they have seen and what they have gone through with; poor cowardly devils they have not done anything but couch themselves up in some hospital or tent and fraim themselves sick.  Studying up all the while to devise some plan to get home, but finding it impossible to get a proper furlough, they openly desert from hospital and regiment, claiming to be badly mistreated.  I hope the citizens will treat them with perfect contempt and as far as possible annoy them so that they will have to return to their command. Beneath Torn and Tattered Flags, Pages 50-51.

Many Mississippians deserted as the war turned against the south and the Yankees ravaged large parts of the state.  It was very tempting for men serving in the army far from their homes to desert when they had wives, children, and family in Mississippi that were in the path of the invading Union armies.

Private Robert M. Holmes of the 24th Mississippi Infantry wrote in his diary how bad news from home affected the men in the ranks:  “Several of the boys received letters this morning from which we learn the sad news that the Yankees are invading the soil of Mississippi very fast.  These letters stated that they were near our homes which causes us to feel very much discontented.” – May 5, 1863.  Kemper County Rebel.

The hardships of a soldier’s life caused many Mississippians to desert; besides being killed or wounded in battle, food was poor and often hard to come by at all, pay was slow in coming, and as the war went on soaring inflation in the south meant that soldier’s could buy very little when they were paid.  Many soldiers desperately wanted to see their families at home, but furloughs were very hard to obtain.

After 1863 armed bands of deserters acted freely in many parts of the state, and in some areas local officials aided these groups in resisting the enforcement of Confederate conscription laws.  The northeast part of the state was one area where there was widespread opposition to conscription and deserters were common.  Poor citizens of counties such as Tishomingo, Pontotoc, and Itawamba had opposed the war from the start, and these areas proved a haven to deserters from the Confederate army.

Another area of the state that had serious problems with deserters was Jones County.  Deserters became so rampant in Jones and surrounding counties in 1864 that in March Colonel Robert Lowry was sent into the area with the 6th and 20thMississippi Infantry Regiments to clean out the region.

Postwar picture of General Robert Lowry from Goodspeed's Biographical and Historical Memoirs of Mississippi, Volume 2.

When he entered Smith County, Lowry had the following notice printed in the local paper:  “To the CITIZENS OF SMITH COUNTY:  I came among you a few days since for the purpose of correcting evils which had well-nigh destroyed your county…You are now free from this curse, and if you will now perform your duties as patriots and freemen you will remain so…When you find in your midst a deserter, secure and send him to his command.  If loyal citizens are ordered from their homes by a band of marauders and house burners, treat them as outlaws and common enemies to mankind.” – Official Records, Series 1, Volume LII, Part 2, Page 658.

After rounding up deserters in Smith County, Lowry moved on to Jones County to deal with one of the most notorious deserters in the state; Newt Knight.  Knight was the leader of an armed band of deserters in Jones County that had plagued Confederate officials for many months.  Lowry pulled no punches in his fight against the Knight and his followers, using dogs to track down the men and torturing them to obtain information about where deserters were hiding.  Lowry also executed a number of deserters who were captured after firing on his men.  Captain William C. Thompson of the 6th Mississippi described the execution of four of these deserters saying, “In front of a military formation and the townspeople the four young men, with their hands tied behind them, were placed in a wagon bed.  Ropes were tied around their necks and fastened to the limb of a large oak tree.  After they had been given time for last prayers the wagon was driven from under them.  This was one of the most revolting sights I had ever witnessed, and I am glad I had no active part in it.” – Civil War Times Illustrated, February 1965.

Colonel Lowry continued the expedition against deserters until early May 1864 when he was ordered to rejoin the army.  During his campaign against the hundreds of men were returned to their commands, nine were hung, two shot, and one wounded at at cost of one of Lowry’s men killed and two wounded.

As the war neared its end in 1865, desertion was rampant in the Confederate armies.  In February 1865 John S. Preston, Superintendent of the Bureau of Conscription, estimated that there were over 100,000 deserters scattered throughout the Confederacy.

A tabulation prepared at the very end of the war by the Confederate War Department showed 198,494 officers and men absent and only 160,198 men present in the Rebel armies on the eve of surrender.

Sources 

            Boatner, Mark M. III.  The Civil War Dictionary.  New York: David McKay Company, 1959.

Dennis, Frank A., Ed.  Kemper County Rebel: The Civil War Diary of Robert Masten Holmes, C.S.A.  Jackson, MS: University & College Press of Mississippi, 1973.

Holmes, Jack D. L.  “The Mississippi County that ‘Seceded’ From the Confederate States of America;”  Civil War Times Illustrated, (February, 1965).

Howell, H. Grady.  For Dixie Land I’ll Take My Stand.  Jackson, MS: Chickasaw Bayou Press, 1998.

Moneyhon, Carl and Bobby Roberts.  Portraits of Conflict: A Photographic History of Mississippi In The Civil War.  Fayetteville, AK: University of Arkansas Press, 1993.

The Official Confederate Roll of Honor.  The Georgia Mint, no date.

Rowland, Dunbar.  Military History of Mississippi 1803-1898.  Spartanburg, SC: The Reprint Company, 1978.

Stiles, Robert.  Four Years Under Marse Robert.  New York: Neale, 1903.

United States War Department, Compiler.  War of the Rebellion: Official Records of the Union and Confederate Armies.  73 Volumes, 128 Parts; Washington, DC: 1880-1902.

Wiley, Bell I.  The Life of Johnny Reb.  Baton Rouge, LA: Louisiana State University Press, 1943.

Woodhead, Henry.  Ed.  Echoes of Glory: Arms & Equipment of the Confederacy.  Alexandria, VA: Time-Life Books, 1991.

 

 

Advertisements
Categories: Uncategorized | 14 Comments

Post navigation

14 thoughts on “Heroes, Conscripts & Deserters

  1. Tristan

    I’ll be following your blog. I have many ancestors who fought in Mississippi units, especially the 3rd Mississippi Infantry. Thanks for doing this.

    • Thanks so much for the kind words. I’m very new at this, but I hope to make the blog both interesting and informative. What company of the 3rd Mississippi was your relative in? I grew up in Bolton, Mississippi, the home of the “Downing Rifles,” Company C of the 3rd Mississippi Infantry, so I have had an interest in the regiment for quite some time.

  2. Tristan

    My ancestors were in companies H, F and E. I’m related to all of the Sauciers in the Regiment. I’d be interested in Company and Regiment info. Thanks much.

  3. Linda Lane

    My GGgrandfather was in the 3rdBattalion Mississippi Infantry Company F”minute men”. I would love to know more about the company. I hope to write a book on my families experience in the war.

    • Linda,
      What was the name of your G-G Grandfather? There were a couple of units designated the 3rd Battalion Mississippi Infantry, and if I had his name I could determine which regiment was his and possibly give you some sources for it.

      • Linda Lane

        His name was E.C.Botts. He was in Co. F and joined from Aug 9-oct 1862. He was 43yrs old and had five kids when he joined. He was a well to do man in 1862. He had an 83 acre farm in Amory.I looked him up on Fold3. It said he was never paid and deserted.Also I found info on an E,C Botts that was in the Gen.Hosp #9 in Salisbury, NC. and he is listed as a citizen, DOD Feb.1864 I know Salisbury was a Confederate POW area.I was shocked to find out this info. Can you help me find his grave or any more info about him. His given name is Eli C. Botts born 1820 in Dekalb, Tn.
        His son, My GGGrandfather was W.S. Botts. He was 16yrs when he joined the12th Miss. Cavalry, Co L. He fought with Col.Armistead. He was recovering from an illness on April 3 ,1864 in Monterallo, Al. when the Union attacked the hospital. He was wounded and taken prisoner He was
        released on May 14,1865. There is another GG Uncle, Capt Botts, he joined in Corinth.
        All my GGGranfathers and their sons were in the Confederacy. Two were wounded and taken prisoner.The Botts clan seem to have disappeared in Miss. after the war.I would love to find out why Eli deserted. Maybe he was afraid for his family and farm. I know many of the soldiers deserted due to fear of their families suffering. His son moved to AR. after the war. I can’t find out what happened to their land
        of their families suffering.

  4. My ancestor served for three months following the Conscription Act of 1862, but then hired a substitute (this is based off of how his widow answered the questions on her pension applications). How would the records reflect this transaction? Would the name of his substitute be in his record? Can it be discovered what became of this substitute?

    I’ve done a search on my ancestor’s name (ancestry.com, family search, National Park Service’s Civil War Soldiers and Sailors database) and have not found him listed in the original company and regiment that his widow said he first signed up with. I found a name very similar to his in the “unfiled” group, but am not sure if this is the right direction to go in for my research (or even how to go about finding this man’s record).

    According to his widow, he was “not discharged” but served until the surrender after he “went off with [the] Militia.” Would you lead me to some sources for understanding the role of the Militia during the war and what kind of documentation there may exist for the hiring of substitutes?

    Your help is greatly appreciated.

    Debra

    • Debra,
      If you could give me some information about your relative (name, date of birth, date of death, where he lived) I will see if I can find anything on him.

      • DKP

        Thank you. His name is Thomas Hosey (spelled several different ways, including Hosse, Hossey, Hossy, Horsey, etc.). He was born 30 Aug 1836 and died 24 Nov 1903. His widow Nancy said that he had originally signed up with Co. A, 40th Miss. Reg. from Jasper County in 1862 (no specific date given). Then, he served for “3 months, then hired substitute.” She said that he was “not discharged” and when asked, “Did he die in the service or did he serve until the close of the war?” she answered, “went off with Militia.” She said that he served until the surrender. He died in Jones County and it was from this county that Nancy made two pension applications: one in 1916 and the other in 1924. She died in 1931 (exact date unknown). Her name last appears on the pension roll in April 1931.

        I’ve continued my research in my recent “discovery” of Jasper County Civil War Records Box 11054 at Family Search. Thomas Hosey has been listed under Co. D, 2nd Inf State Troops, Jasper County. A variation of his name (Thomas Horsey) appears on the list from that same record box for the Co. A, 40th Miss. Reg. (this is the same company his widow Nancy reported).

        As a side note, Rufus Clayton, the captain of Co. A, Oak Bowery Invincibles, was killed in the Battle of Iuka. (http://www.findagrave.com/cgi-bin/fg.cgi?page=gr&GRid=28164509) I’m concerned that the substitute that Thomas hired may have also fallen in this same battle. Would a substitute be assigned to the same regiment as the one who hired him?

        Relatives of his, among them William T. Hosey and Captain Benjamin Franklin Moss (for whom Moss, Mississippi is named) served in the CSA from the beginning to the end of the war, I believe (in the same company–Co. E, 8th Inf.–as Newton Knight!). Just from what I’ve been able to gather thus far, Thomas’s war record seems greatly different, but it might have been because he was wanting to stay home to look after his widowed mother (with whom he is enumerated in the 1860 Federal Census) and the farm and family. I can’t say what his motivations were for hiring a substitute, but am curious as to why he would do such a thing while his peers apparently volunteered early on and he entered only when drafted.

        I’m also wondering if Thomas’s serving in the militia would pit him against Newton Knight and his group of deserters, since he was living in the same area (Jones and Jasper counties).

        In the “Unfiled Papers of the Confederate Soldiers” list, Thomas might be the T H Hossey listed, but I’m not sure (I don’t know what his middle initial was). His relative William might also be on this list (as William Hossey) as well.

        Your offer to help solve the mystery of Thomas’s service record is greatly appreciated.

  5. Daryl Johanson

    I am researching my ancestor’s enlistment. He was a widower with three young boys under 10. I see no exemption in Mississippi for his service. The only state that I found that exempted widowers was the Union state of Pennsylvania. My ancestor was E.F. Jackson, from Itawamba County, Company E, 12th Battalion Mississippi Cavalry.

  6. Colonel Preston Brent, 38th Mississippi is my great, great grandfather. Growing up (I was born in 1959) the family spoke of him in glowing; almost reverent terms. He has a monument at Vicksburg where he surrendered after the siege (Commanded sharp-shooters) and had been shot.
    He has been a source of pride for me. We had his swords, gold CSA buttons, uniform, payment papers and gold pocket watch which we gave back to Mississippi because each generation sub divided them. We did keep the papers he signed saying he would not take up arms against the United States of America again.
    The internet has been a source that validated a lot of what I heard about Colonel Preston Brent…some childhood stories are well stories or greatly embellished. Thank you for this post.
    My oldest son graduated from West Point in May, 2013; in his gray (Frankenstein) uniform he looks remarkably like the Colonel.

    • Lee,
      Thanks so much for responding! Colonel Brent is very near and dear to me, as I spent quite a bit of time researching his life while I was working on my regimental history of the 38th Mississippi. I have been in contact with a number of Brent’s descendants over the years, and it is great to hear from another one. I have a good bit of information on Colonel Brent, and I would be happy to share what I have with you. I would also love to talk with you about the artifacts belonging to Colonel Brent that you mentioned in your post. You can contact me directly at: championhilz@att.net.

  7. Joseph Brent Walker

    I was so glad to see the article about Col Preston Brent and the email from Lee Brent about his artifacts. I too am a great great grandson and would appreciate knowing where those artifacts can be seen and to share info about him. I don’t know where Lee Brent is or how to contact him but please give him my email address and my email. Thanks for your service to the history of our country and of Mississippi. I have never known what happened to those artifacts. I have Col Brent’ textbooks from his Kentucky military school days with notes about his classmates and copies of what appear to be speeches he gave to his community and to his troops.

    • lbrentnj

      Thank you for forwarding this. I dd not see his email.

      Feel free to share my email address with Joseph Brent Walker.

      Best,

      Lee

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Blog at WordPress.com.

%d bloggers like this: